Most bad articleship experiences were visible at the interview. The partner did not answer a question, the stipend was “to be discussed”, registration was “later”. This page lists the flags that matter, ties each to the ICAI rule that sits behind it and gives you a scorer to apply to your own offer.
The flags, and the rule behind each
| Flag | Why it matters | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Fee demanded for a seat | Not a legitimate practice for a training position | Walk away |
| Stipend below the minimum | Regulation 48 fixes a floor. See the table | Walk away |
| Joining before registration | Days before valid registration do not count. See registration | Walk away |
| Cash-only stipend | No proof if payment stops. See stipend not paid | Negotiate |
| Hours above 35 a week as routine | ICAI's norm is 35, up to 45 in exceptional cases. See working hours | Negotiate |
| Leave refused or discouraged | Leave is earned under Regulation 59. See leave rules | Negotiate |
| No named reviewer | Work without feedback is slow learning | Ask more |
| Only one narrow task type | You may finish two years without a full toolkit | Ask more |
| Many trainees leave early | Ask current trainees why | Ask more |
Score your offer
Red flag scorer
Tick every statement that is true for the offer you are considering.
What to do with each level
- Walk away flags: decline politely and keep looking. See the Hyderabad vacancy guide.
- Negotiate flags: ask for the term in writing before joining. Use the confirmation email in our email samples.
- Ask-more flags: speak to a current trainee and ask the reviewer's name. Compare offers with the offer scorecard.
If you already joined
- Document everything: hours, payments and messages.
- Raise issues in writing and politely.
- Know your exit route. See the transfer rules. Never leave without the process.
Frequently asked questions
What are the red flags when choosing a CA firm for articleship?
A fee for the seat, a stipend below the Regulation 48 minimum, joining before registration and a refusal to confirm terms in writing are the serious ones. Cash-only pay, routinely long hours and a vague leave policy are negotiable. No named reviewer or narrow work should prompt more questions.
Is it a red flag if the firm does not pay the stipend on time?
Yes if it is a pattern. A single delay can be fixed with a written reminder. Repeated delay is covered in our guide on what to do when stipend is not paid.
Can a firm refuse to register me?
Registration needs the principal's approval on the ICAI portal. A firm that keeps postponing it is putting your training days at risk, so do not start before it is done.
How do I check whether a firm treats trainees well?
Speak to two current or recent trainees and ask about stipend regularity, hours, leave and who reviews work.
What if I notice red flags after joining?
Document the facts, raise them in writing and use ICAI's grievance route if needed. Transfers follow ICAI's rules, so do not leave without the process.