Comerze › Blogs › Articleship

Red Flags to Avoid When Choosing a CA Firm for Articleship: A Checklist and Risk Scorer

The warning signs worth acting on, each tied to the rule behind it, and a scorer for your own offer.

By Comerze DeskUpdated 8 November3 min read

Linked to Regulations 48, 59 and the working-hours announcement on 8 November

Most bad articleship experiences were visible at the interview. The partner did not answer a question, the stipend was “to be discussed”, registration was “later”. This page lists the flags that matter, ties each to the ICAI rule that sits behind it and gives you a scorer to apply to your own offer.

The flags, and the rule behind each

FlagWhy it mattersLevel
Fee demanded for a seatNot a legitimate practice for a training positionWalk away
Stipend below the minimumRegulation 48 fixes a floor. See the tableWalk away
Joining before registrationDays before valid registration do not count. See registrationWalk away
Cash-only stipendNo proof if payment stops. See stipend not paidNegotiate
Hours above 35 a week as routineICAI's norm is 35, up to 45 in exceptional cases. See working hoursNegotiate
Leave refused or discouragedLeave is earned under Regulation 59. See leave rulesNegotiate
No named reviewerWork without feedback is slow learningAsk more
Only one narrow task typeYou may finish two years without a full toolkitAsk more
Many trainees leave earlyAsk current trainees whyAsk more

Score your offer

Red flag scorer

Tick every statement that is true for the offer you are considering.

What to do with each level

  1. Walk away flags: decline politely and keep looking. See the Hyderabad vacancy guide.
  2. Negotiate flags: ask for the term in writing before joining. Use the confirmation email in our email samples.
  3. Ask-more flags: speak to a current trainee and ask the reviewer's name. Compare offers with the offer scorecard.
Look at firms before you applyProfiles, locations and openings on Comerze.
Browse CA firms →

If you already joined

  • Document everything: hours, payments and messages.
  • Raise issues in writing and politely.
  • Know your exit route. See the transfer rules. Never leave without the process.

Frequently asked questions

What are the red flags when choosing a CA firm for articleship?

A fee for the seat, a stipend below the Regulation 48 minimum, joining before registration and a refusal to confirm terms in writing are the serious ones. Cash-only pay, routinely long hours and a vague leave policy are negotiable. No named reviewer or narrow work should prompt more questions.

Is it a red flag if the firm does not pay the stipend on time?

Yes if it is a pattern. A single delay can be fixed with a written reminder. Repeated delay is covered in our guide on what to do when stipend is not paid.

Can a firm refuse to register me?

Registration needs the principal's approval on the ICAI portal. A firm that keeps postponing it is putting your training days at risk, so do not start before it is done.

How do I check whether a firm treats trainees well?

Speak to two current or recent trainees and ask about stipend regularity, hours, leave and who reviews work.

What if I notice red flags after joining?

Document the facts, raise them in writing and use ICAI's grievance route if needed. Transfers follow ICAI's rules, so do not leave without the process.

Open the Comerze MarketplaceCourses, free formats, tools and software for CA, CS and CMA students.
Browse tools and courses →
Sources and where to verify. Rules, dates and fees change. Confirm on the official page before acting.

Keep reading

Tools & courses for CA studentsMarketplace