Comerze › Blogs › Accounting and Finance

Depreciation: Straight-Line vs Written Down Value, With Numbers

One asset, two methods, two different profit figures in the early years.

By Comerze DeskUpdated 18 November4 min read

Reviewed by Comerze Desk

The two methods

  • Straight-line: (cost less residual value) divided by useful life
  • Written down value: a fixed percentage applied to the opening book value each year

A worked example

A machine costs Rs 1,00,000, has a residual value of Rs 10,000 and a useful life of 5 years. For the written down value method, take a rate of 20%.

YearStraight-line (Rs)Written down value (Rs)
118,00020,000
218,00016,000
318,00012,800

Straight-line: (1,00,000 − 10,000) / 5 = 18,000 every year. Written down value: 20% of 1,00,000, then 20% of 80,000, then 20% of 64,000.

Effect on profit

  • Written down value lowers profit more in the early years
  • Over the whole life the total charge is the same only when both methods end at the same residual value
  • Changing the method is a change in accounting estimate and needs disclosure

Accounting and tax are separate

The Companies Act sets out useful lives for classes of assets in a schedule and allows either method. Depreciation for income tax follows its own rules and rates, so the figure in the books and the figure for tax often differ.

Pro tipKeep a fixed asset register

Cost, date of use, method, rate and residual value for every asset make depreciation, audit and tax work much quicker.

FAQs

Which method is better?

Neither is better in every case. Straight-line suits assets used evenly, and written down value suits assets that lose value faster at first.

Is land depreciated?

Generally not, because it does not have a limited useful life.

What happens when an asset is sold?

The difference between the sale price and the book value is a profit or loss on disposal.

Keep reading

Tools & courses for CA studentsMarketplace